Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Peadar Morgan's avatar

Just one word: Wow!

Expand full comment
Sheila's avatar

Fascinating as ever! The Pictish stone at Edderton could also perhaps be a Moreb boundary marker? Living in Cromarty, I am always confused (and disappointed too!) that we don't have our own large Sculptured Stone, but your thesis of a boundary running through the Cromarty Firth could explain why we don't (unless it is in the later medieval church foundations or lost to the sea). Looking at the 'visibility arcs' of the Easter Ross sculptured stones, they certainly show Easter Ross pointing towards Moray, whereas a large Stone on eg the South Sutor would have added another large visibility arc into the Moray Firth if Ros and Moreb were part of the same polity. Having two substantial monasteries (Rosemarkie and Portmahomack) quite close together does beg the question of why, but if they are the ecclesiastical centres of different polities, that adds weight to your proposed areas for the two polities. If 'cill names' reflect an early gaelic influence in Ros, is there any significant equivalent church placename distribution in Moreb? And if Ros and Moreb DID have an alliance in the 880/890s to defeat the Norse, I wonder how long it lasted and if it established/reinforced/stabilised/informed the norse southern fringe through the black isle (going on place names) rather than the norse pressing further south? So many rabbit holes and I look forward to more!

Expand full comment
5 more comments...

No posts